26 Nov
2004
26 Nov
'04
2:34 a.m.
El jue, 25-11-2004 a las 18:41, Tom Insam escribió:
In conversation yesterday, Kake told me of her idea to store discussion pages in a special metadata field that is read and displayed and formatted and edited just like a normal node content field, by giving the special argument action=discuss to the script. I like this idea a lot.
Tom disagrees. You'd clog the version history of the main page with commentary. It really needs to be a separate page.
I agree with Tom, a commentary should not make a new version of the main node. I think the Mediawiki approach is a good one. You can, of course, create a separate namespace for comments, but I think it would be harder to do.
My $ 0.2...